Fortescue shares (ASX: FMG) continued their downward trajectory this week, closing down 2.99%, and critically below the $15level. In closing at $14.94, Fortescue’s share price also made a new 52 week low at $14.86 on the day, with the year high of $27.67 a long way away.
 

 

The recent single-day decline is symptomatic of a broader, sustained negative trend that has weighed heavily on investor sentiment. Over the past month alone, Fortescue shares have shed 10.59%, with the YTD decline of 20.5% and 12 month 40% demonstrating consistent bearish pressure.

The fundamental backdrop largely explains the share price pressure. Fortescue’s most recent half-year results, reported in February 2025 for H1 FY25, highlighted the direct impact of fluctuating iron ore prices on its bottom line. Despite achieving record shipment volumes – a testament to its operational capabilities – the company reported a 20% year-on-year decline in revenue to US$7.6 billion. The impact on profitability was even more pronounced, with Net Profit After Tax (NPAT) plummeting 53% to US$1.6 billion compared to the prior corresponding period. This profit squeeze underscores the company’s sensitivity to the underlying commodity market, a factor overriding its production efficiency in the recent reporting period.

Despite the earnings headwinds and share price depreciation, Fortescue continues to offer a compelling proposition for income-focused investors via its substantial dividend. The trailing dividend yield is currently estimated between 8.88% and 9.04%, a significant return in the current market, though future payouts will naturally depend on profitability. Valuation metrics present a mixed signal, with the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio varying considerably from approximately 5.25 to 8.15, depending on whether trailing or forward earnings are used and the specific calculation methodology. The lower end of this range might suggest undervaluation to some, but hinges heavily on the future earnings trajectory.

🟩 The Bull Case for FMG

  • High Dividend Yield: Offers a significant trailing yield around 9%, appealing for income generation.
  • Operational Resilience: Demonstrated ability to achieve record shipments (H1 FY25), showcasing production strength.
  • Potential Valuation Floor: Lower end P/E ratio (approx. 5.25) could signal undervaluation if earnings stabilize.
  • Analyst Upside Potential: Highest analyst price target sits at AUD $21.00, suggesting considerable recovery potential.
  • Long-Term Green Transition: Implicit potential (mentioned in news context) from Fortescue Energy transformation, though carries execution risk.

🟥 The Bear Case for FMG

  • Severe Share Price Decline: Significant negative performance across 1-month, 3-month, YTD, and 1-year periods, testing 52-week lows.
  • Bearish Technical Signals: Trading below key 50-day and 200-day moving averages indicates negative momentum.
  • Sharp Profitability Drop: H1 FY25 saw substantial declines in revenue (-20%) and NPAT (-53%) due to external price pressures.
  • Weakening Earnings Forecasts: Analyst estimates point to potential declines in full-year earnings and revenue.
  • Commodity Price Exposure: Highly vulnerable to volatile iron ore prices, currently impacting margins significantly.
  • Analyst Caution: Consensus ‘Hold’ rating and lowest price target (AUD $15.03) align closely with the current depressed share price.
  • Elevated Recent Volatility: 1-Year Beta (1.24) indicates higher volatility compared to the broader market recently.

Estimates for the next half-year point towards a potential Earnings Per Share (EPS) of AUD $1.02 and revenue of AUD $11.70 billion. However, tempering expectations are broader analyst forecasts suggesting a potential year-over-year decline in earnings for the full fiscal year 2024, with some estimates reportedly being revised downwards significantly from previous projections (e.g., from US$1.68 to US$1.33 per share). Revenue forecasts are also reflecting a decreasing trend, aligning with concerns over sustained iron ore price weakness.
 

 

 

Top Australian Brokers

 

Analyst consensus currently sits at a ‘Hold’ rating, reflecting the balancing act between Fortescue’s operational strength, attractive dividend, and the significant challenges posed by commodity price volatility and the uncertain outlook. Price targets span a wide range, from a low of AUD $14.9 (effectively the current price) to a high of AUD $20.79, demonstrating a clear divergence between the bulls and bears regarding the company’s near-term prospects and the long-term potential associated with its strategic pivot towards green energy through its Fortescue Energy division.

Operational updates are likely to prove critical in determining the next phase for Fortescue’s shares, with fundamentals key in reshaping sentiment.
 

Don’t Buy Just Yet

You will want to see this before you make any decisions.

Before you decide which shares to add to your portfolio you might want to take a look at this special report we recently published.

Our experts picked out The 5 best ASX shares to buy in 2025.

We’re giving away this valuable research for FREE.

Click below to secure your copy

Secure your FREE copy