Lynas Rare Earths shares (ASX:LYC) have started 2025 in fine form, with gains of 19.14% year-to-date. This marks a significant outperformance to the ASX 200’s negative 5.52% return over the same period. But not all has been smooth sailing.
As the world’s largest producer of separated rare earth elements outside of China, Lynas Rare Earths holds a pivotal long-term strategic position in the global shift towards electrification and green technologies. The company, crucial for its supply of neodymium (Nd) and praseodymium (Pr), essential components in high-performance magnets for electric vehicles (EVs), wind turbines, and sophisticated electronics, is contending with the realities of commodity price cycles even as future demand for its products appears strong.
The primary source of recent pressure into early April had been the softening market prices for rare earth elements. This directly impacted Lynas’s financial performance in the first half of Fiscal Year 2025 (ending December 31, 2024), leading to a significant profit slump reported in late February 2025. A more than 10% pullback followed, with the stock finding support at $6.85 and rallying to the current level. These swings highlights the inherent sensitivity of miners, even strategically vital ones, to global commodity price fluctuations. Compounding these market woes were certain production setbacks, underscoring the operational complexities involved in extracting and processing these critical minerals across its integrated operations, spanning the Mount Weld mine and Kalgoorlie processing facility in Western Australia to its separation plant in Malaysia.
Despite the margin compression witnessed in the first half, the forward-looking consensus appears markedly more optimistic. While the trailing twelve-month Earnings Per Share (EPS) sits modestly at around AUD $0.05, forecasts for the quarter ending June 2025 anticipate an improvement to approximately AUD $0.07. More compellingly, analysts project a dramatic surge in long-term earnings, with some estimates pointing to an annual growth rate nearing a staggering 59%. The consensus view is that Lynas will achieve profitability for the full Fiscal Year 2025, suggesting the recent slump is viewed as a temporary setback rather than a fundamental deterioration. Investors are keenly awaiting the full-year results, expected around late August 2025 (estimated Aug 21-26).
Analyst sentiment, reflected in price targets, captures this dichotomy between near-term pain and long-term gain. Target prices exhibit a wide dispersion, ranging from a cautious AUD $5.10 to a highly bullish AUD $9.50. The average consensus target tends to cluster around the AUD $7.05 to $7.40 range, closely aligning with the current trading price. This spread likely reflects differing analyst weighting of the immediate market headwinds versus the undeniable long-term secular demand growth driven by global decarbonisation efforts and the strategic imperative for non-Chinese rare earth supply chains.
Top Australian Brokers
- City Index - Aussie shares from $5 - Read our review
- Pepperstone - Trading education - Read our review
- IC Markets - Experienced and highly regulated - Read our review
- eToro - Social and copy trading platform - Read our review
Lynas Rare Earths embodies the tension between cyclical industry challenges and profound strategic importance. Its role as a key ex-China supplier of materials critical to the energy transition provides a powerful long-term narrative. However, investors must weigh this against the immediate realities of volatile commodity prices, operational execution risks, and the resulting impact on near-term profitability.
Don’t Buy Just Yet
You will want to see this before you make any decisions.
Before you decide which shares to add to your portfolio you might want to take a look at this special report we recently published.
Our experts picked out The 5 best ASX shares to buy in 2025.
We’re giving away this valuable research for FREE.
Click below to secure your copy
