Silver and its minersโ stocks have had a tough year. They plunged with gold in spring and summer as extreme Fed tightening catapulted the US dollar parabolic. The resulting deep lows left this tiny fringe contrarian sector deeply out of favor, but it has started recovering in recent months. The major silver minersโ upside potential is partially dependent on their fundamentals, which were just detailed in new quarterlies.
The silver-stock universe is vanishingly small by stock-market standards, with the leading sector ETF only commanding a trifling $969m in net assets this week. That remains the SIL Global X Silver Miners ETF. After launching way back in April 2010, it has grown into silver stocksโ main benchmark. SILโs dreadful price action this year certainly explains why silver stocks have been mostly abandoned by traders, left for dead.
Early on SIL actually got off to a solid start, rallying 23.4% between late January to mid-April. But then the bottom fell out, with the major silver stocks cratering a catastrophic 45.5% by late September! While SIL has rebounded 34.1% at best since then as of Thanksgiving eve, it was still down 21.3% year-to-date. All that selling was fueled by silver breaking down with gold on the Fedโs most-extreme tightening ever.
The white metal itself rallied 20% from mid-December to early March, plunged 30.4% into late September, and then mean reverted 19.8% higher into mid-November. Those moves amplified parallel gold swings by 1.3x, 1.5x, and 2.2x. The far-smaller silver market usually depends on the way-bigger gold market to set the psychological tone. With gold and silver plunging as the US dollar soared, silver stocks were scorned.
Thatโs understandable since price action drives sentiment, but unfortunate given silverโs super-bullish backdrop. Traders flock back to silver after gold powers high enough for long enough to convince them a decisive sustainable upleg is underway. Also temporarily derailed by that red-hot wildly overcrowded long-dollar trade, goldโs upside potential is massive with the first inflation super-spike since the 1970s now raging.
Top Australian Brokers
- eToro - market-leading social trading platform - Read our review
- IG - Extensive product array and user-friendly platforms - Read our review
- IC Markets - experienced and highly regulated - Read our review
- Avatrade - powerful trading tools - Read our review
Gold nearly tripled in monthly-average-price terms during the 1970sโ first inflation super-spike, then more than quadrupled during the second! Monthly-average silver prices from those same trough-to-peak CPI months enjoyed colossal 184.4% and 448.5% gains! Silver ought to multiply again before this current inflation super-spike runs its course. Silver investment demand will skyrocket as gold mean reverts way higher.
That will catapult silver prices sharply higher. Interestingly the white metalโs own fundamentals are very strong. The Silver Institute collects and publishes the best-available data on silverโs global supply and demand. While the resulting reports are only published annually, SI just gave a mid-November update on 2022โs silver demand. It reported total global demand is tracking to hit a record 1,210m ounces this year!
That would make for outstanding 15.7% year-over-year growth even while silver prices languish sapping investorsโ interest. Physical silver investment is faring even better, with SI now estimating it is going to surge 18.3% YoY to a record 329m ounces in 2022! If that is already happening now despite miserable silver price action, imagine how demand will explode when silver soars attracting in far more investors.
Silverโs huge upside potential amplifying gold during this inflation super-spike is incredibly bullish for the silver minersโ stocks. Their earnings really leverage material silver-price moves. The question now is how are they faring fundamentally before silver shoots stratospheric again? Their latest Q3โ22 earnings season wrapping up in mid-November revealed the major silver miners are actually doing surprisingly well!
For 26 quarters in a row now, Iโve painstakingly analyzed the latest results released by SILโs 15-largest component stocks. These include the worldโs biggest silver miners, now accounting for a commanding 88.1% of this ETFโs entire weighting. Digesting hard fundamental results as they are released is essential for cutting through obscuring sentiment fogs. It helps traders rationally understand silver stocksโ real outlook.
This table summarizes the operational and financial highlights from the SIL top 15 during Q3โ22. These major silver minersโ stock symbols arenโt all US listings, and are preceded by their rankings changes within SIL over this past year. The shuffling in their ETF weightings reflects shifting market caps, which reveal both outperformers and underperformers since Q3โ21. Those symbols are followed by current SIL weightings.
Next comes these minersโ Q3โ22 silver and gold production in ounces, along with their year-over-year changes from the comparable Q3โ21. Output is the lifeblood of this industry, with investors generally prizing production growth above everything else. After that is a measure of silver minersโ relative purity, their percentage of quarterly sales actually derived from silver. Most silver miners also produce gold or base metals.
Generally the more silver-centric a miner, the more responsive its stock price is to changing silver prices. So traders looking for leveraged silver exposure via its minersโ stocks should overweight purer producers. Then the costs of wresting that silver from the bowels of the earth are shown in per-ounce terms, both cash costs and all-in sustaining costs. The latter subtracted from average silver prices help illuminate profitability.
That is followed by these minersโ hard quarterly revenues and earnings reported to national securities regulators. Blank data fields mean companies hadnโt reported that particular data as of mid-November when Q3โs earnings season was winding down. Annual percentage changes are excluded if they would prove misleading, like comparing two negative numbers or data shifting from positive to negative or vice versa.
With weaker silver prices last quarter, it was a challenging time for silver miners. Yet their Q3 results still proved considerably better than I expected. While raging inflation forced mining costs higher to strangle profitability, the SIL-top-15 silver miners largely held the line. Their mining costs rose much slower than the major gold minersโ costs last quarter, which I discussed last week with similar analysis on GDX gold stocks.
Production is always of paramount importance for silver miners, but even more so when silver prices are weak. That was certainly the case in Q3โ22, when quarterly-average silver prices plunged 20.7% YoY to just $19.23. Those were the worst silver prices by far in nine quarters! Silver fared way worse than gold, which saw its quarterly-average prices slump just 3.5% YoY to $1,727. That really pressured silver miners.
The top 25 GDX gold miners suffered an outsized 4.1% YoY decline in their aggregate Q3โ22 gold output. Yet the SIL top 15 somehow managed to merely see their total silver production slip a small 0.9% YoY to 77,309k ounces! That was even more impressive considering a major composition change with one of this ETFโs top holdings. SIL booted the Russian-owned UK-listed Polymetal International earlier this year.
For years Polymetal had been SILโs second-largest component, a larger producer yielding 399k ounces of gold and 4,500k of silver in the comparable Q3โ21. But after Russia invaded Ukraine and started inflicting cruel destruction on its people and cities, global investors dumped Russian stocks in protest. So Polymetalโs market capitalization cratered, which alone wouldโve bludgeoned it out of these elite SIL-top-15 ranks.
That wasnโt the end of Polymetalโs woes, as its Big Four accounting firm resigned as its auditor back in early April. Deloitte warned it was no longer safe to audit Polymetalโs extensive Russian operations. It faced delisting in London without an auditor, and extensive international sanctions against Russia also threatened to impact its mines. Polymetal was effectively replaced in the SIL top 15 by a small explorer.
While Adriatic Metals is currently constructing its maiden silver mine in Bosnia, it wonโt start producing until Q3โ23 at best. So the SIL-top-15 results really arenโt comparable between Q3โ21 to Q3โ22 with a big producer exchanged for an explorer. Excluding Polymetal from those year-ago totals, the SIL top 15โs total silver production actually surged a big 5.2% higher YoY! That is radically better than the major gold miners.
A majority of the SIL-top-15 silver miners actually grew their silver output last quarter, a higher proportion than among GDX-top-25 gold miners. And this growth wasnโt trivial, averaging hefty 15.1% YoY gains excluding MAG Silver which is ramping up a big new mine. So the silver miners greatly outperformed on the critical production front in Q3โ22, at least with silver. Yet their gold production still shrunk considerably.
These elite major silver miners saw their collective gold output plunge 34.2% YoY to 1,045k ozs. But that too is heavily distorted by Polymetal getting kicked out of this ETF. Exclude its gold output from Q3โ21, and that slashed last quarterโs year-over-year decline to a more-reasonable 12.1%. And even that was skewed by another anomalous event, SSR Miningโs gold production crashing 51.5% YoY to just 77k ounces!
That sounds apocalyptic, but thankfully it was only temporary. In late June SSRM discovered a small cyanide leak at its primary gold mine in Turkey, from a pipeline running to its leach pad. This was quickly cleaned up and fixed, but local regulators didnโt authorize mining to resume until late September. So that mineโs gold output was almost totally lost in Q3โ22! It is back online now and ramping up in this current Q4.
Had that run at Q3โ21 levels last quarter, the SIL top 15 excluding Polymetal wouldโve only seen their total gold production retreat 5.5% YoY. Thatโs still considerable, but a far cry from that unadjusted 34.2% shocker! The major silver miners generally boosting their silver production as gold output slumps has improved their silver purity a bit. They averaged 39.4% of their Q3โ22 sales from silver, 1.6% better than Q3โ21.
Four of these elite silver miners qualified as primary silver ones, deriving over half their revenues from silver. Their purity percentages are boldfaced in blue in this table. But the SIL-top-15 average will likely resume slipping in coming quarters. SSRMโs full gold output bouncing back will be one key driver, as its purity percentage soared from 11.8% in Q2โ22 to 31.6% in Q3โ22 with its primary gold mine briefly suspended.
That mine coming back online will drag the overall SIL-top-15 purity average about 1.3% lower. But silver outperforming gold in coming quarters could more than offset that. Silver prices are more beaten down than gold ones, and silver tends to amplify major gold advances by roughly 2x. So if silver rallies faster than gold on their coming mean reversions with the Fed-fueled parabolic US dollar surge dying, purity could rise.
Like their major-gold-miner peers, the silver miners faced mounting inflationary pressures on their mining costs last quarter. In normal times, silver-mining unit costs are generally inversely-proportional to silver-production levels. Thatโs because silver minesโ total operating costs are largely fixed during pre-construction planning stages, when designed throughputs are determined for plants processing silver-bearing ores.
Their nameplate capacities donโt change quarter-to-quarter, requiring similar levels of infrastructure, equipment, and employees to keep running at full-speed. So the only real variable driving quarterly silver production is ore grades fed into these plants. Those vary widely even within individual silver deposits. Richer ores yield more ounces to spread miningโs big fixed costs across, lowering unit costs and boosting profitability.
But while fixed costs are the lionโs share of silver mining, there are also sizable variable costs. Energy is the biggest category, including electricity to power ore-processing plants like mills and diesel fuel to run excavators and dump trucks hauling raw ores to those facilities. Other smaller consumables range from explosives to blast out ores to chemical reagents necessary to process various ores to recover their silver.
Many of the SIL top 15โs latest quarterly reports complained about this raging inflation. Major silver miner Pan American Silverโs inflation warning was representative, declaring โall operations were negatively impacted by inflationary pressures, mainly reflecting increased prices for diesel and certain consumables, including cyanide, explosives, and steel products (such as grinding media), as well as supply-chain shortages.โ
PAASโs explanation continued โWe are also experiencing indirect cost increases in other supplies and services due to the inflationary impact of diesel and consumable prices on third-party suppliers.โ Inflation forcing mining costs higher makes it harder to profitably produce silver. But the SIL top 15 did a great job tightening their belts, as evident in relatively-constrained jumps in both of their key unit costs last quarter.
Cash costs are the classic measure of silver-mining costs, including all cash expenses necessary to mine each ounce of silver. But they are misleading as a true cost measure, excluding the big capital needed to explore for silver deposits and build mines. So cash costs are best viewed as survivability acid-test levels for the major silver miners. They illuminate the minimum silver prices required to keep the mines running.
The SIL top 15โs cash costs did surge 9.0% YoY to $11.03 per ounce in Q3โ22. Thatโs the highest on record, probably ever but definitely in the 26 quarters Iโve been advancing this research thread. But still that increase was much better than the GDX-top-25 gold minersโ blistering 22.4% YoY cash-cost surge last quarter! The major silver miners appear to be managing their variable mining costs better than gold miners.
All-in sustaining costs are far superior than cash costs, and were introduced by the World Gold Council in June 2013. They add on to cash costs everything else that is necessary to maintain and replenish silver-mining operations at current output tempos. AISCs give a much-better understanding of what it really costs to maintain silver mines as ongoing concerns, and reveal the major silver minersโ true operating profitability.
The SIL-top-15 silver minersโ AISCs climbed a similar 7.0% YoY to $15.85 in Q3โ22. That too proved the highest in the last 26 quarters and likely ever witnessed. But again this magnitude of cost increase seems quite constrained given the severe inflation ravaging silver miners. That alone is probably running well over 7%, so these companies are apparently controlling their costs much more effectively than gold miners.
The GDX top 25โs average AISCs in Q3โ22 soared 21.9% YoY to their own all-time-record peak of $1,391! That equated to 1.17x the prior four quartersโ average AISCs. But the SIL top 15โs milder cost increases left that same ratio better at 1.09x. The major silver miners are either better managing their costs, or there are less AISC outliers skewing their average than the GDX gold miners are contending with today.
Still those high AISCs along with weaker silver prices largely garroted silver-mining profits last quarter. Again quarterly-average silver prices plunged 20.7% YoY in Q3โ22 to just $19.23. Subtracting those high average AISCs of $15.85 from silver yields implied sector unit profits of just $3.38 per ounce. That didnโt just collapse a brutal 64.2% YoY, but it is the SIL top 15โs worst by far since all the way back in Q1โ20!
In the eight quarters before Q3โ22, this sector-unit-profits proxy averaged a whopping $10.87 per ounce. So the major silver minersโ profitability is definitely impaired by low silver prices and surging inflation-fueled costs. But this pinching should really moderate in coming quarters, enabling unit earnings to quickly soar back near normal levels. Higher silver prices are coming as the white metal amplifies the yellowโs surge.
With the Fedโs parabolic US-dollar surge rolling over and unwinding, thereโs no reason gold and silver canโt mean revert back up near their Q1โ22 averages before the Fedโs extreme tightening. Those ran $1,879 and $24.03. Quarterly-average silver prices would have to power up 25.0% from Q3โ22 levels to regain Q1โ22 levels! Also some of the SIL-top-15 miners themselves are forecasting lower AISCs ahead.
Pan American Silver is a great example. Last quarter its AISCs climbed a reasonable 10.2% YoY to hit $17.97. Yet this company just reaffirmed its full-year AISC guidance in its Q3โ22 results, at $15.25 per ounce. In 2022โs first couple quarters, PAASโs AISCs averaged $15.36. To hit the that midpoint forecast of $15.25, Q4โs would have to come in near $12.30. Expecting SIL-top-15 AISCs to retreat to $14.00 is conservative.
At $24 silver and $14 AISCs, SIL-top-15 unit profits would nearly triple back up near $10 per ounce! That isnโt likely in this current Q4, as silver has only averaged $20.05 quarter-to-date. But higher silver prices are very likely in 2023 and beyond as gold mean reverts much higher to better reflect this raging inflation unleashed by extreme central-bank money printing. Silver-mining earnings are destined to head much higher.
On the hard-accounting front under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles or their equivalents in other countries, the SIL top 15โs revenues definitely suffered with lower silver prices and less gold production. They plunged 22.1% YoY to $4,941m in Q3โ22, reflecting that 20.7% lower average silver and 5.5% lower adjusted gold output. But if Polymetalโs sales are removed from Q3โ21, that revenue drop moderates to 10.5%.
Actual bottom-line accounting earnings reported to securities regulators proved dismal for the SIL top 15 last quarter, cratering 94.5% YoY to just $16m! And even that was skewed high by Wheaton Precious Metals, which reported a $104m gain on selling a mineral-stream interest. SilverCrest Metals also had a big $26m forex gain as it ramps up its new silver-and-gold mine. So silver minersโ GAAP profits were ugly.
But higher silver prices will work wonders to catapult silver-miner profitability higher. The SIL top 15โs cash flows generated from operations are a better measure of their financial health than easily-distorted earnings. OCFs blasted up 50.7% YoY to $471m in Q3โ22, but that too is skewed. In Q3โ21, Buenaventura paid a colossal $544m for tax litigation to the government of Peru! Without that, overall OCFs fell 45.0% YoY.
But the SIL top 15โs cash treasuries still remained robust, adding up to $5,887m exiting Q3โ22. That actually climbed a slight 2.6% YoY, and wasnโt affected by Polymetalโs booting since it didnโt report cash in its Q3โ21 report. The major silver minersโ big cash hoards will help them continue to grow their output, both by expanding existing mines and developing or buying new ones. Higher silver prices will accelerate that.
If you regularly enjoy my essays, please support our hard work! For decades weโve published popular weekly and monthly newsletters focused on contrarian speculation and investment. These essays wouldnโt exist without that revenue. Our newsletters draw on my vast experience, knowledge, wisdom, and ongoing research to explain whatโs going on in the markets, why, and how to trade them with specific stocks.
That holistic integrated contrarian approach has proven very successful, yielding massive realized gains during gold uplegs like this overdue next major one. We extensively research gold and silver miners to find cheap fundamentally-superior mid-tiers and juniors with outsized upside potential as gold powers higher. Our trading books are full of them starting to really surge.
The bottom line is major silver miners are actually faring pretty well fundamentally despite the depressed silver prices. They are growing their collective silver production, which along with weaker gold output is boosting their relative purity. That makes their stock prices more responsive to the coming higher silver levels as gold mean reverts higher to reflect this raging inflation. Silver will amplify goldโs upside like usual.
The silver miners are also doing a good job managing mining costs, which only climbed by single-digit percentages last quarter. That was just a third of what gold miners suffered! The silver miners are also projecting lower costs in coming quarters, which along with better silver prices will really boost profitability. The silver stocksโ solid fundamentals even in this challenging Q3โ22 support much higher prices as silver recovers.
Published by Adam Hamilton of Zeal LLC Specialising in stock-market speculation and investment from a contrarian perspective. This material has been prepared for general information purposes and must not be construed as investment advice.