Melius Research downgraded Oracle Corporation to Hold from Buy, reflecting growing Wall Street concern over the software giant’s aggressive infrastructure investments and their impact on cash generation through the end of the decade.

 

 

 

Oracle Shares Downgraded

Oracle shares traded at $154.88 on February 9, 2026, up $12.06 or 8.44% from the previous close, despite the downgrade. The stock opened at $148.49 and fluctuated between an intraday low of $142.09 and a high of $155.20, with volume reaching 8.2 million shares. The positive price action suggests markets may have already priced in concerns about Oracle’s capital-intensive strategy, or that other factors are driving near-term optimism.

 

Top Australian Brokers

Melius Research analyst Ben Reitzes set a $160 price target on the stock, just 3.3% above current trading levels. The downgrade represents a significant shift in perspective, with Reitzes noting that Oracle should be valued “more akin to an infrastructure company vs. a software company” given its current business trajectory.

 

Analysts Cite Cash Flow Concerns

The Melius downgrade centers on a fundamental question about Oracle’s valuation framework: “What should a stock sell for with no free cash flow until the 2030s?” This concern stems from Oracle’s substantial capital expenditure program to build out AI and cloud infrastructure capabilities, which the company views as essential to competing with hyperscalers like Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud.

While Reitzes acknowledged CEO Larry Ellison’s ambition, stating the firm “admires Larry Ellison for ‘going for it here,'” he warned that debt and equity considerations “will be an overhang for some time.” The analyst’s commentary suggests Oracle’s transformation from a traditional software vendor to an infrastructure provider carries significant financial implications that markets must reckon with.

The downgrade follows similar moves by other major Wall Street firms. Morgan Stanley analyst Keith Weiss slashed his price target from $320 to $213 while maintaining an Equal-weight rating, projecting cash capital expenditures of approximately $275 billion between fiscal 2026 and 2028. Weiss warned this spending could push adjusted debt above $400 billion and increase leverage beyond 5x, creating balance-sheet and credit rating risks.

DA Davidson also reduced its target from $300 to $200 with a Neutral rating, reflecting broader analytical concern about Oracle’s ability to finance its expansion while maintaining financial flexibility.

According to Melius Research analyst Ben Reitzes, Oracle “may just be a tough slog as debt and equity will be an overhang for some time.”

Morgan Stanley’s Keith Weiss noted that Oracle’s infrastructure expansion could “significantly impact earnings per share and increase capital expenditures beyond market expectations.”

 

Oracle Outlook and Analysis

The wave of downgrades highlights a fundamental tension in Oracle’s investment thesis. On one hand, the company is positioning itself to capture substantial AI infrastructure demand, with management pointing to a growing backlog of cloud contracts. On the other, the capital required to build that infrastructure is straining traditional software economics and pushing out the timeline for meaningful free cash flow generation.

Markets now face the challenge of valuing Oracle through a hybrid lens—part software company with high margins and recurring revenue, part infrastructure provider with heavy capital intensity and longer payback periods. This valuation complexity is compounded by Oracle’s reliance on a concentrated group of large AI customers, creating revenue concentration risk if demand patterns shift.

The technical picture shows Oracle trading well below analyst price targets set just months ago, suggesting either targets were too optimistic or that fundamental concerns have accelerated faster than expected. With multiple firms now clustering around $200 price targets or below, markets appear to be resetting expectations for Oracle’s near-term trajectory.

 

ORCL Analyst Summary

Bull Case

  • Oracle’s AI infrastructure investments position company for long-term cloud market share gains
  • Growing contract backlog demonstrates strong demand for Oracle’s cloud computing capabilities
  • Stock trading below recent analyst targets may present attractive entry point for patient investors

Bear Case

  • No meaningful free cash flow generation expected until 2030s strains traditional valuation models
  • Debt levels potentially exceeding $400 billion create significant balance sheet and refinancing risks
  • Revenue concentration among few large AI customers increases business model volatility and dependence

The infrastructure buildout strategy could ultimately prove prescient if AI workload demand materializes as Oracle anticipates, but the path from here involves navigating substantial financial risk, elevated debt levels, and an extended period without the free cash flow generation that typically characterizes successful software businesses. Markets will likely remain cautious until Oracle demonstrates it can convert infrastructure investments into profitable, sustainable revenue streams without compromising its balance sheet integrity.

The Bull Team
The Bull Team is a group of finance writers and journalists that provide commentary and insights on the Australian stock market and beyond.