QBE Insurance shares (ASX: QBE) have broken through to price levels not seen since before the global financial crisis, trading at A$24.68 and climbing 24% year-to-date through 2026, as markets reward a multi-year transformation that has delivered materially stronger underwriting results, robust premium growth, and disciplined capital management.

The QBE share price rounded out Wednesday’s session at A$24.56, having made a new high at A$24.68, a return to territory last visited in 2009. The stock has posted gains of approximately 11% over the past three weeks alone, with bulls now making the breakout that had been marked out on charts. The next test will be the hold.

Fundamental Backdrop Support QBE Move

The catalyst for QBE’s surge to decade-plus highs arrived on 20 February 2026, when the company reported full-year 2025 results that exceeded expectations across virtually every metric. Net profit after tax jumped to US$2.16 billion from US$1.78 billion in 2024, while adjusted net profit rose to US$2.13 billion. More importantly for long-term investors, adjusted return on equity reached 19.8%, a level that places QBE firmly in the top tier of global commercial insurers and represents a dramatic improvement from the mid-single-digit returns that characterised much of the previous decade.

Gross written premium grew 7% on a reported basis, or 8% excluding exited portfolios, comfortably ahead of management’s mid-single-digit growth guidance. This performance was underpinned by targeted premium increases averaging around 2% across the group in the first quarter of 2026, with stronger rate momentum of approximately 4% in segments outside the increasingly competitive commercial property and Lloyd’s markets.

 

Top Australian Brokers

The group combined operating ratio—the key profitability metric in insurance that measures claims and expenses as a percentage of premiums—improved to 91.9% from 93.1% in 2024, beating the company’s own target of approximately 92.5%. A combined ratio below 100% indicates underwriting profit, and QBE’s sustained performance in the low-90s represents a structural shift from the mid-to-high-90s ratios that previously constrained returns.

Portfolio optimisation has played a central role in this transformation. Over recent years, QBE has systematically exited underperforming and volatile segments, including certain North American middle-market commercial lines, while refocusing capital on higher-margin businesses such as crop insurance and specialty lines. This strategic reshaping has reduced catastrophe volatility and improved the overall quality of the underwriting book, with management emphasising a more balanced geographic and product mix in investor materials.

Buybacks Return Capital To Holders

Alongside the strong operating results, QBE announced an on-market share buyback programme of A$450 million, running from December 2025 through 2026 and funded from surplus capital. This marks a significant shift for a company that historically prioritised balance sheet repair over shareholder distributions, and markets have interpreted the buyback as a clear signal that management believes the improved earnings trajectory is sustainable rather than cyclical.

The capital return comes as QBE has also moved to optimise its debt structure. The company priced €500 million of new subordinated regulatory-capital debt and fully redeemed US$524.1 million of legacy 5.875% subordinated notes as of 17 June 2026. The refinancing of higher-coupon legacy debt into more cost-effective capital is incrementally earnings-accretive and demonstrates the financial flexibility that comes with a stronger balance sheet and credit profile.

Guidance Reaffirmed

On 8 May, QBE issued its first-quarter trading update and reaffirmed full-year 2026 guidance, describing a “pleasing” start to the year underpinned by targeted premium growth, resilient underwriting discipline, and effective investment management. The company reiterated expectations for mid-single-digit gross written premium growth and a group combined operating ratio of approximately 92.5% for the full year.

The reaffirmation so soon after the February results announcement has de-risked the near-term outlook and reinforced market confidence that 2025 was not a one-off beneficiary of benign catastrophe losses and favourable pricing conditions. Management highlighted continuing premium growth momentum and still-positive rate increases in most segments, though acknowledged intensifying competition in commercial property and at Lloyd’s, where the company is increasingly relying on volume growth and favourable mix shifts to sustain overall premium expansion.

External validation of the improved trajectory has come from S&P Global Ratings, which expects QBE’s net income to remain around US$2 billion in 2026 and beyond, citing the company’s diversified global book and improved underwriting discipline. Industry publications have similarly noted QBE’s steady premium expansion, strong investment gains, and multi-year track record of catastrophe losses running below budget.

Markets are now grappling with whether QBE’s return to 2009-era share price levels is justified by fundamentals or whether the stock has run too far, too fast.

Bull Case:

  • Structural profitability reset: 19.8% ROE and sub-92% combined ratio sustainable
  • Capital returns and debt refinancing demonstrate confidence in earnings durability
  • Portfolio optimisation reduces volatility; crop and specialty growth prospects strong
  • Positive external validation from S&P and industry analysts supports higher multiple
  • Pricing still positive in most segments; multi-year cat losses below budget

Bear Case:

  • Valuation reflects near-perfect execution; limited upside if cycle turns or cats normalise
  • Competition intensifying in commercial property and Lloyd’s; pricing momentum slowing materially
  • History of strategic churn and market exits raises execution and consistency concerns
  • Sharp retail premium increases risk regulatory intervention or adverse customer selection
  • Several benign cat years may have flattered results; reversion could pressure margins

For now, QBE Insurance shares stand as one of the ASX’s strongest performers in 2026, having successfully navigated a multi-year transformation that has taken the shares from the wilderness of chronic underperformance back to levels that reflect a fundamentally stronger, more disciplined, and more profitable business. It will now be important in the upcoming sessions to see exactly how markets react to the breakout. Will volume support the move and provide a new floor for holders, or will a pullback be on the cards that looks to test earlier highs?

The Bull Team
The Bull Team is a group of finance writers and journalists that provide commentary and insights on the Australian stock market and beyond.