Contact Energy shares (ASX: CEN) closed at their lowest level in nearly 3 years, with the A$7.09 level last matched in Dec 2023. With the move coming not long after one of the strongest results in its history, there are those wondering it the stock is now a bargain, or a value trap in the making?
The move appears to reflect a market still re-pricing dilution, execution risk and power-price normalisation, even as the underlying earnings engine has clearly improved.
Looking to the recent results, and the FY26 numbers, delivered in August, were strong. Management framed the year as “a year of delivery”, and the figures backed the language: EBITDAF of NZD 1,011 million, up 31%, net profit of NZD 423 million, up 62%, operating free cash flow of NZD 648 million, up 49%, and return on invested capital up 100 basis points to 5.9%.
The Manawa Energy acquisition and a step-change in renewable output have left the company with around 98% renewable generation, while hydro inflows and national storage ran well above average. Generation costs have collapsed, with wholesale unit costs down roughly 41% year-on-year in the February operational data.
Yet the market keeps focusing on the other side of the ledger, as revenue fell 5% to 6% in FY26 as average electricity prices normalised to around NZD 140 per MWh from NZD 157, a reminder that part of the margin story is weather and asset mix rather than pricing power.
Top Australian Brokers
- Pepperstone - Top Australian broker - Read our review
- eToro - Invest in ASX and international shares - Read our review
The company raised around NZD 575 million of new equity in February, on top of earlier follow-on offerings, to de-lever and fund four utility-scale renewable projects spanning batteries, solar and geothermal, plus acquisitions including Manawa and King Country Energy. The investment programme totals roughly NZD 1.4 billion, an unusually large commitment for a utility of this scale, with higher-for-longer rate expectations punishing capex-heavy, leveraged names first.
View From The Street
The analyst community is firmly on the other side, with the average rating at ‘buy’, and with a price target of 10.63, implying significant upside from here. The technical setup however does little to challenge the bears right now. The price sits below the 50-day moving average at 7.47, which itself sits below the 200-day at 7.80.
The intraday, and multi year low at A$7.07 level is now the line that matters, with the psychological A$7 handle next. A decisive break below it would confirm the downtrend and likely invite a fresh wave of systematic selling, while a sustained hold, combined with visible progress on project milestones, stable hydro conditions or any softening in rate expectations, would strengthen the case that the market has over-discounted the risks. For now, the share price is voting with the trap thesis; the earnings, and the Street, are voting with the bargain.
Bull Case:
- Record FY26 earnings, free cash flow up 49%, returns on capital improving.
- Roughly 98% renewable generation with structurally lower costs after the Manawa acquisition.
- Consensus target near NZD 10.63 implies close to 50% upside from lows.
Bear Case:
- Repeated equity raises have diluted holders, and balance sheet leverage remains elevated.
- NZD 1.4 billion project pipeline carries execution, timetable and further funding risk.
- Margins lean on favourable hydro conditions; softer power prices could squeeze earnings.
