Commonwealth Bank of Australia shares (ASX:CBA) have staged a technical recovery this week, rebounding from deeply oversold conditions to reclaim the psychologically important A$160 level. The move follows a punishing month-long slide of more than 11%, with the debate over the bank’s premium valuation still very much alive.


Ahead of the final trading session of the week, CBA shares had added 2.12%, recovering from a low near A$155 and holding above weekly support in the A$158–A$159 zone. The bounce carried the stock back through A$160 and up toward A$161, the level marking its year-to-date breakeven point. Despite the bounce on the week, the stock remains down 0.34% through 2026 and 11.14% lower over the past month, having retreated sharply from an all-time high above A$185.

The shift in momentum has seen CBA’s RSI climb from a deeply oversold reading near 24 to a more neutral 42.29. Technically minded traders have interpreted the defence of the mid-A$150s, an area that also aligns with long-term moving averages, as evidence of support.

Fundamentals Mixed

The recovery comes against a mixed fundamental backdrop. CBA’s FY26 full-year results were objectively strong: cash net profit after tax rose 7.1% to A$10.982 billion, operating income grew 6.2% to A$30.22 billion, and the net interest margin held steady at 2.05%. The bank reported market share gains across all five core domestic divisions and declared a fully franked final dividend of A$2.70 per share, taking the full-year payout to A$5.05. Its CET1 capital ratio of 12.0%, a 79% deposit funding ratio and 90-plus-day home loan arrears of just 0.73% underscore the franchise’s defensive qualities.

 

Top Australian Brokers

Yet the results triggered a “sell on the news” response, with markets unwilling to extend already-stretched valuation multiples for roughly 7% profit growth. Loan impairment expenses rose 9% to A$788 million, and management flagged slowing household consumption and broader economic deceleration.

Macro conditions have added further complexity. Stronger-than-expected inflation data prompted economists, including those at ANZ, to price in a potential 25 basis point RBA cash rate hike to 4.60%. Australian 10-year government bond yields surged toward 5.19%, national home loan applications fell roughly 15%, and national home values declined 0.9% in August. Separately, the RBA’s decision to cut credit card interchange caps from 0.80% to 0.30% is expected to strip an estimated A$660 million in annual fee revenue from the banking sector.

What Comes Next?

The valuation disparity sits at the heart of the debate, as CBA trades on a trailing price-to-earnings ratio of approximately 24.6x with a dividend yield around 3.1%, while major peers ANZ, NAB and Westpac trade between 17.2x–19.5x with yields around 4.4%. The average analyst price target for CBA sits at A$125.21, implying 22% downside from current levels if the Street is right.

From a technical standpoint, the near-term picture is more constructive. A decisive break above A$161 would confirm the recovery and open a path toward retesting higher resistance, while failure at that level could see the stock drift back toward A$158–A$159 support, with A$155 the key line below. Fundamentally, higher interest rates could offer some margin support on CBA’s vast low-cost deposit base, but they simultaneously raise the risk of mortgage stress, slower credit growth and higher impairment charges.

Bull Case:

  • Oversold RSI rebound and A$160 reclaim signal strong institutional support near A$155.
  • FY26 cash profit rose 7.1% with steady margins, sector-leading capital and low arrears.
  • Higher interest rates could expand net interest margins on CBA’s low-cost deposit base.

Bear Case:

  • CBA trades near 24x earnings versus peers around 19x despite modest profit growth.
  • Consensus price targets of A$120–A$128 imply roughly 20–25% downside from here.
  • Higher rates, falling home values and card fee caps threaten credit growth and income.
The Bull Team
The Bull Team is a group of finance writers and journalists that provide commentary and insights on the Australian stock market and beyond.