Xero Limited shares (ASX: XRO) have tumbled to a new low, wiping out the substantial gains made in 2024, signalling growing concerns among markets regarding the company’s strategic direction and competitive positioning. The recent decline underscores a challenging period for the cloud accounting software provider.
Xero’s share price hit a new low of A$112.35 in trading today, closing down 0.46% on the day and a further 5.18% over the week. This extends a bearish trend throughout 2025, with the stock now down 32.63% year-to-date and 19.4% in the past month alone. This reverses the gains seen in 2024, returning the stock to levels last seen in February of that year.
A key factor influencing this downturn was the June acquisition of U.S.-based payments platform Melio for US$2.5 billion. To finance this acquisition, Xero conducted a A$1.85 billion institutional placement, issuing new shares at A$176 each, a 9.4% discount. The share price reacted negatively, dropping 9% following the announcement, reflecting market apprehension about the acquisition’s price tag and potential integration hurdles.
The company’s half-year results, released in November, showed a 20% increase in operating revenue to NZ$1.2 billion. However, the share price still fell by 4% to A$134.80 as markets focused on softer performance metrics in North America. Including transaction costs associated with the Melio aquisition, the operating expense to revenue ratio was 77%.
Adding to the pressure, analysts have voiced concerns regarding Xero’s ability to compete effectively in the U.S. market against established players like Intuit. The expensive Melio acquisition has further amplified these concerns, raising questions about its impact on operating income.
Top Australian Brokers
- Pepperstone - Top Australian broker - Read our review
- eToro - Invest in ASX and international shares - Read our review
Furthermore, controversy surrounding CEO Sukhinder Singh Cassidy’s remuneration package has fueled shareholder discontent. At the annual general meeting in August, nearly half of shareholders voted against the board’s remuneration report. During Xerocon in September, Cassidy defended her USD 15.2 million target remuneration, a move that coincided with a 5.7% drop in the share price.
Despite the prevailing bearish sentiment, some analysts remain optimistic. Macquarie maintains an “Outperform” rating, projecting a potential 88.4% upside over the next 12 months, driven by anticipated growth in average revenue per user (ARPU) through price increases and product enhancements.
Xero’s stock faces headwinds from acquisition costs, competitive pressures, and corporate governance concerns. While some analysts foresee a potential rebound, the markets currently reflect a cautious outlook, leaving the company at a critical juncture, with the stock at near 2 year lows.
