Liontown shares (ASX: LTR) fell almost 5% yesterday, as the quarterly update revealed a sharp drop in spodumene output, rising unit costs, and softer revenue. None of these are good news, and particularly so for a stock that is already 56% down on the year.
The Liontown share price rounded out the day at A$0.67, extending a run that has left holders nursing losses of 27.96% for the month heading into its final trading session.
What Did Liontown Report
The September quarter (Q1 FY27) actually showed strong underground mining momentum, against a near-term operational drag stemming from the processing of legacy open-pit stockpiles.
Spodumene concentrate production fell 24% quarter-on-quarter to 78,000 dry metric tonnes (dmt), while total sales came in at 82,600 dmt. The culprit was the deliberate drawdown of open-pit ore stockpiles, which introduced elevated levels of gabbro contamination into the plant feed. That contamination pushed process plant recoveries down to 60%, compared with 63% in the prior quarter, and as low as 70% when the plant is fed clean underground ore alone — a meaningful gap that illustrates the transitional nature of the current operating phase.
The recovery degradation, combined with fixed operating costs of approximately A$104 million being spread across a reduced sales volume, drove unit operating costs up 27% quarter-on-quarter to A$1,259 per tonne (FOB). That figure sits modestly above the top end of Liontown’s full-year FY27 guidance range of A$1,050 to A$1,250 per tonne — a breach that, while management attributes to the transitional feed mix, markets were unwilling to overlook.
Top Australian Brokers
- Pepperstone - Top Australian broker - Read our review
- eToro - Invest in ASX and international shares - Read our review
Revenue Lower
Revenue fell 15% quarter-on-quarter to A$199 million, down from A$235 million in the June quarter, reflecting the lower shipped volumes. The revenue decline was partially cushioned by a firmer realised price, with Liontown achieving an average of US$1,966 per tonne CIF on a spodumene concentrate 6% equivalent basis, roughly 5% higher quarter-on-quarter and a relative bright spot in an otherwise challenging report.
On the cash flow front, underlying operating cash flow remained positive at A$69 million, though statutory operating cash flow was clipped to A$46.6 million after a one-off A$22 million customer settlement outflow. The company ended the quarter with A$502 million in cash, down from A$561 million at June 30, and moved to a net cash position of A$146 million with gross debt gearing at a manageable 19%.
Record Underground
Underground mining, meanwhile, delivered a record quarter. Liontown advanced 4,021 metres of underground development, up 21% quarter-on-quarter, and mined 389,000 tonnes of underground ore at a 1.4% lithium oxide grade, up 9% quarter-on-quarter, as plant availability reached a record high of 94%. Full-year production guidance of 390,000 to 440,000 dmt were held along with its cost guidance, with the expectation that unit economics will normalise as underground ore displaces open-pit material as the primary plant feed.
Liontown’s board also approved a A$389 million expansion of the Kathleen Valley processing facility, lifting nameplate capacity from 2.8 million tonnes per annum to 4.2 million tonnes per annum. The project is designed to more than double annual concentrate output to approximately 780,000 tonnes by FY30, positioning the company as one of Australia’s larger hard-rock lithium producers when the cycle eventually turns.
What Next?
The company’s own guidance acknowledges that unit costs should normalise as underground ore becomes the dominant feed source, and the record underground development metrics suggest that transition is progressing. If plant recoveries can be sustained at or near the 70% level demonstrated with clean ore, the cost profile should improve materially over the coming quarters.
The A$389 million expansion approval signals board-level confidence in the long-term demand outlook for battery-grade lithium and in Liontown’s ability to fund growth from its substantial cash reserves. But at the same time, committing to large-scale capital expenditure during a period of lithium price weakness and operational cost pressure is a decision that markets are likely to scrutinise closely.
Liontown will head towards the final months of the year within three cents of a 52 week low, and a chart that leans heavily bearish on a technical front. Below all major moving averages, and with an RSI of 33.67, it may take a shift in sentiment towards lithium names in order to provide some much needed relief.
Bull Case:
- Realised spodumene prices rose 5% q/q to US$1,966/t, outperforming spot market weakness.
- Record 4,021m underground development accelerates transition to higher-grade, cleaner ore feed.
- Plant recoveries reach 70% on clean underground ore, signalling strong normalisation potential.
- A$502M cash reserve and net cash position of A$146M provide a robust cyclical buffer.
- Board-approved A$389M expansion targets 780ktpa output by FY30, doubling production capacity.
Bear Case:
- Unit costs of A$1,259/t breach the top end of full-year FY27 guidance range.
- Production fell 24% q/q and revenue dropped 15% q/q in a single quarter.
- Plant recoveries slipped to 60% due to open-pit stockpile contamination issues.
- A$389M expansion commits significant capex during a period of lithium price weakness.
- A$22M one-off customer settlement reduced statutory cash flow and signals commercial risk.