BlueScope Steel shares (ASX: BSL) added 3.51% to start the week at A$31.00, building on what has been an impressive 50% gain over the past 12 months.
Monday’s close at A$31.00 marked a decisive reclaim of two closely watched technical levels for BSL shares. After a period of consolidation that saw the stock drift toward its rising 200-day simple moving average (SMA) at A$30.25, buyers stepped in at that support zone and pushed the stock back above the 30-day SMA at A$30.65 in a single session. The move is technically bullish, with a bounce off a rising 200 day SMA following consolidation a continuation of momentum
Recent Financials Provide Support
The headline financial result driving sentiment is a 72% year-over-year surge in underlying earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) to A$1.27 billion. That result is particularly notable given the headwinds the company navigated to achieve it, including softer Australian flat steel pricing and elevated raw material input costs that weighed on domestic segment margins.
The earnings recovery was driven primarily by two factors: expanded steel spreads at BlueScope’s North Star mini-mill in Delta, Ohio, where U.S. trade tariffs have tightened domestic supply dynamics and lifted hot-rolled coil (HRC) margins; and record despatch volumes from its premium Australian brands, COLORBOND and TRUECORE, which achieved their highest-ever Australian despatch figures during the period.
Top Australian Brokers
- Pepperstone - Top Australian broker - Read our review
- eToro - Invest in ASX and international shares - Read our review
North Star, an electric arc furnace (EAF) facility, is structurally well-positioned to benefit from U.S. protectionist steel policy, given its low-cost production model and exposure to domestic construction and manufacturing demand. The mill’s recent debottlenecking and capacity expansion program further positions BlueScope to capture incremental volume upside should U.S. demand conditions remain supportive.
On the corporate governance front, BlueScope’s board made headlines earlier this year after unanimously rejecting an unsolicited takeover approach from a consortium led by SGH Limited and US based Steel Dynamics. The initial offer of A$30.00 per share, and subsequent sweetened proposals reaching up to A$32.35 per share, were each dismissed by management as materially undervaluing the company’s asset base and long-term growth potential.
Rather than entertain the consortium’s advances, BlueScope’s board pivoted to a shareholder return commitment, pledging to deliver A$3.00 per share in direct capital returns in financial year 2027. That pledge effectively establishes a tangible income floor for shareholders while reinforcing management’s conviction that intrinsic value sits well above the rejected bid range.
What Next?
Tom Fairchild of Lazarus Capital Partners, who flagged BSL as a Hold in this week’s share tips, noted that the company’s pricing power is primarily generated from premium brands such as COLORBOND and TRUECORE, which achieved record Australian despatches, and that U.S. tariffs lifting steel spreads at its Ohio-based North Star mill also assisted its pricing power.
From a capital allocation perspective, the A$3.00 per share FY2027 return commitment is a meaningful signal of balance sheet confidence, but it also raises the bar for execution. Management will need to demonstrate that the capital return can be funded without compromising investment in growth projects or stretching leverage metrics, particularly if earnings moderate from their current cyclical highs.
Momentum has been tested in recent weeks, and with the latest move showing support at the rising 200 day SMA, the longer term bull trend remains in tact. The overhead 50 day at A$31.46 would represent a near term break out of consolidation, with the range between the two narrowing by the day.
Bull Case:
- Underlying EBIT surged 72% year-over-year, demonstrating strong operational leverage across geographies.
- North Star mill benefits structurally from U.S. tariff policy and low-cost EAF production model.
- A$3.00 per share FY2027 capital return commitment provides a tangible income floor for shareholders.
- Record COLORBOND and TRUECORE despatches confirm durable premium brand pricing power in Australia.
- Rejected takeover bids signal board confidence in intrinsic value well above current share price.
Bear Case:
- Cyclical HRC spread compression in the U.S. could rapidly erode North Star’s outsized earnings contribution.
- Australian segment margins remain under pressure from soft pricing and elevated raw material costs.
- Broker Hold ratings suggest limited near-term upside with stock near rejected takeover bid levels.
- Capital return commitment raises execution bar, potentially constraining balance sheet flexibility.
- Shares remain 12% below 52-week highs, reflecting unresolved uncertainty around earnings durability.