Morgan Stanley has reshuffled its metals ratings, upgrading Ivanhoe Mines to Overweight while downgrading Alcoa shares (ASX: AAI) and Vale to Equal-weight, as the investment bank backs copper and precious metals over aluminium and iron ore heading into 2027.
Alcoa’s share price closed 2.21% lower ahead of Friday’s session, with markets also reacting to softer than expected China data. The moves from Morgan Stanley reflect a changing supply outlook that favours base metals tied to energy transition and precious metals over bulk commodities facing rising output and softer demand.
Metals Forecast Shifts
Looking closer at the shift, the firm lifted its price target on Ivanhoe Mines to C$13.20 from C$12.00, citing attractive entry pricing after prolonged underperformance following the seismic disruption at the Kakula copper mine.
The bank expects operational execution through 2026 and a positive mine plan update in early 2027 to support a rerating of the shares.
In the opposite direction, Morgan Stanley downgraded both Alcoa and Vale shares to Equal-weight, cutting price targets on concerns about supply dynamics in their core markets.
Top Australian Brokers
- Pepperstone - Top Australian broker - Read our review
- eToro - Invest in ASX and international shares - Read our review
The bank now forecasts the global aluminium market will shift into surplus as Middle Eastern smelters restart production faster than expected, with new supply coming online in Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, India, and Angola. Morgan Stanley cut its aluminium price forecasts for 2027–28 by 11% to 13%, warning that Alcoa’s high operating leverage could push earnings well below market expectations.
Vale’s downgrade reflects weaker iron ore market conditions, as the bank sees persistent pressure on pricing amid softer Chinese demand and rising seaborne supply.
The supply dynamics outlined by Morgan Stanley have clear implications for ASX-listed miners outside of Alcoa, particularly those with copper, iron ore, and aluminium exposure.
Copper bulls will find support in the bank’s view that supply discipline and restocking by utilities are keeping the market tight. That’s positive for any ASX miners with meaningful copper exposure, especially those tied to African or South American projects where production growth remains constrained.
On the other hand, iron ore producers face a less optimistic outlook. Morgan Stanley’s caution on Vale signals broader concerns about Chinese demand and rising global supply, which could weigh on the earnings of major ASX iron ore names if the thesis plays out. Aluminium’s shift into surplus is another headwind.
Precious metals also feature in the upgrade case, with the bank expecting gold and silver to outperform. That view aligns with recent strength in gold prices and may support gold trading sentiment in the second half of the year.
What comes next?
Morgan Stanley expects Ivanhoe Mines to deliver improved operational performance through 2026, with a mine plan update due in early 2027 that could provide further clarity on production growth and capital allocation.
Vale’s trajectory depends on Chinese demand and whether seaborne iron ore supply continues to grow. Any signs of stronger Chinese stimulus or infrastructure spending could offset some of the downside risk, but the base case from Morgan Stanley suggests caution.
For Alcoa, the timeline hinges on how quickly aluminium oversupply materialises. If Middle Eastern restarts accelerate and new capacity ramps up in Indonesia and India as forecast, the surplus could weigh on prices by late 2026 or early 2027.
The AAI share price sits at the lowest close of 2026 at A$69.51, with the A$70 support level breaking ahead of the final trading session of the week. Whilst the shares remain 48% higher over a trailing 1 year period, calendar 2026 has presented a far more nuanced picture.
After a 45% YTD rally in the stock into early June, the shift in sentiment has been dramatic, with a 40.5% drawdown in a little over 1 month, that leaves holders looking at losses YTD of 13.5%. A downgrade into a stock that has slipped into oversold territory, with a 28 RSI would not be the start to the second half of the year that bulls were looking for.
