At least three institutional investors in Australia are pushing for global miner BHP to consider external candidates to replace Andrew Mackenzie as new CEO, sources with direct knowledge of the matter say.
The move highlights nascent investor pressure on the world’s biggest miner to consider drastic changes in management to tackle challenges like cutting costs, an eventual return to lower iron ore prices and rebuilding its reputation after a Brazil dam disaster.
“We are quite firmly of the view that it needs to be an external candidate… We just don’t see anybody internally that could make a material improvement to the status quo,” one of the three institutional investor sources said.
“They pretty much miss every operational target they set, both in terms of costs and volumes, so it’s very hard to take new project proposals at face value,” the person said.
The topic has gained traction in talks in Perth and Sydney in the past few weeks, two other investors said.
The three investors together hold less than a combined one per cent stake in BHP, according to Refinitiv data.
They all declined to be named due to the sensitivity of the subject.
Mackenzie has been in the job for almost seven years.
BHP hired its last external CEO in 1998 when it brought in Paul Anderson to reform the company, which he did by instigating its takeover of Anglo-South African miner Billiton.
It is not immediately clear whether top BHP investors also share the view that it needs substantial cultural change at the top management to give the miner the reform it needs.
Norway’s $1 trillion sovereign wealth fund, a major shareholder in BHP Billiton, declined to comment.
Activist shareholder Elliott Capital and Blackrock also declined to comment.
A BHP spokesman said it did not comment on speculation.
BHP’s performance has improved in the past 12 months after a change in chairman and the tailwind from rising iron ore prices that may mean Mackenzie could extend his run.
But it flagged $US1 billion ($A1.42 billion) in productivity losses for fiscal 2019 in its quarterly production report last week flowing from disruptions to operations across its commodities.
“It is… felt by investors that there is substantial cultural change that can be effected in order to achieve this and in time it will require a change of management to make this happen,” said a second institutional investor source.
They pointed to Nev Power who was instrumental in turning Fortescue Metals into the world’s the world’s fourth-largest – and lowest-cost – iron ore producer in under a decade, or Newcrest’s Sandeep Biswas as possible candidates.
“Nev is held in high regard for having achieved this through his career,” the second source said.